PiBang vs. Raspbian: what's the difference?

PiBang versus Raspbian

Revised July 17, 2013.

The major differences are the choice of desktop environment, the init system, the default file manager, the default shell and our setup utility.

1. Desktop: Openbox instead of LXDE

Raspbian uses LXDE. PiBang uses the lighter Openbox window manager together with Tint2 as a panel and Nitrogen as a wallpaper handler. The lighter desktop leaves room for heavier programs like AbiWord, Geany and Gnumeric.

Openbox has probably been overlooked in Raspbian because its menu items are a little harder to change. PiBang installs most of the programs you will need by default and already has them in the menu, which is one reason the image is larger than Raspbian. The team worked hard to bring many of the menu tweaks originally written by Philip Newborough of the CrunchBang project to the Raspberry Pi, which makes editing the menu much easier.

2. Init system: SystemD

Raspbian ships with Debian’s default SysV init. PiBang switched to SystemD. Most major distributions have switched, and future Debian versions look set to follow. For you this means faster boots and simpler init scripts.

3. Software repositories

Raspbian has built a large, impressive software repository. It’s so good that we use it as our base. On top of it we run our own repositories with software that is newer, not offered, too custom or too experimental for Raspbian. You get a cutting edge while staying on a solid foundation.

4. File manager: SpaceFM

LXDE uses PCManFM by default, while PiBang uses SpaceFM. They are quite similar, but SpaceFM, while slightly heavier, offers enough extra features to be worth it.

5. Default shell: ZSH

Bash has been the default on most Linux distributions for a long time. Every PiBang edition ships with ZSH as the default shell. System scripts still use /bin/sh, which is still a symlink to Dash, and Bash stays installed because it’s part of the Debian/Raspbian base.

6. A forked raspi-config

PiBang forked the raspi-config program, at first to add missing features. Many of those features have since been accepted upstream, and we keep pushing the program further to improve security.

Who should use PiBang, and why?

The PiBang project is not centered on education. It has two goals: a simple, reliable server edition ready for cool projects without Raspbian’s bloat, and a full-featured desktop that isn’t designed for the classroom. Educational programs like Scratch are left out, and programs useful to everyone else are installed.

PiBang still uses the Raspbian sources, so it stays compatible. Programs we added or changed will not be affected by regular updates, and you get the same stability as hard-float Raspbian with more functionality. If you need a fast, powerful desktop or a light server edition, PiBang is for you.